Key points
- Force-based design checks a building's strength and stiffness; performance-based design shows how badly it would be damaged in a strong earthquake.
- The R factor in force-based design is an assumption about ductility. A performance-based check can test whether that assumption holds.
- Halim High-Speed Railway Station was checked with performance-based design because the Jakarta review panel saw it as both a building and a bridge.

Most buildings in Indonesia are designed with force-based design. For buildings with an unusual function, engineers and review panels sometimes ask for an additional check: performance-based seismic design (PBD). This article explains the difference between the two, using a real example: Halim High-Speed Railway Station.
Force-based design: the standard approach
In force-based design, the engineer derives the design earthquake force from the SNI 1726 response spectrum and divides it by the response modification factor R. The structure is then designed to resist this reduced force. Its ability to deform beyond the elastic limit without collapsing (ductility) is provided by reinforcement detailing in line with the concrete code.
Force-based design delivers two results:
- Strength: are beams, columns and slabs strong enough for the load combinations?
- Stiffness: are storey drifts within the allowed limits?
Halim Station was designed this way in early 2019 in ETABS, following SNI 1726:2012 (seismic) and SNI 2847:2013 (reinforced concrete). At that time SNI 1726:2019 and SNI 2847:2019 had not yet been officially published. The seismic parameters were:
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Location | East Jakarta |
| Ss / S1 | 0.713 g / 0.307 g |
| Fa / Fv | 1.27 / 2.77 |
| Site class | SE (soft soil) |
| Seismic design category | D |
| R / Ω0 / Cd | 8 / 3 / 5.5 |
| Importance factor Ie | 1.25 |
An importance factor of 1.25 corresponds to risk category III in SNI 1726, the category for buildings that hold large numbers of people.
The limitation: R is an assumption
R represents the ductility and reserve strength expected from a structural system. Force-based design does not directly check whether the finished design actually has that capacity. Nor does it answer the question owners often ask: how badly would my building be damaged in a major earthquake?
For most buildings, design to SNI is sufficient. For buildings with more complex behaviour, that question matters.
Performance-based design: judging behaviour, not only strength
Performance-based design is a method to design or evaluate a structure by its performance level. The performance level describes how much damage the structure suffers in a strong earthquake: usable straight away, damaged but occupants safe, or close to collapse. The ATC-40 guideline notes that this understanding helps engineers plan more effective and cost-efficient retrofits.
| Aspect | Force-based design | Performance-based design |
|---|---|---|
| Main question | Are members strong and stiff enough? | How does the building behave in a strong earthquake? |
| Analysis | Linear (elastic) | Nonlinear (beyond the elastic limit) |
| Output | Strength and stiffness | Building performance level |
| Use | Every building, required by SNI | Additional check for specific cases |
Methods used in PBD
There are several ways to carry out a performance-based check:
- Static pushover analysis: the structure is pushed with steadily increasing horizontal forces following the first and second mode shapes.
- Modal pushover analysis: the structure is pushed in every mode and the results are combined with the CQC or SRSS method.
- Time history analysis: the structure is subjected to recorded ground accelerations, either linearly or nonlinearly.
For Halim Station, static pushover analysis was chosen because the building is regular and not tall. Tall or irregular buildings usually need a more complete method.
Why Halim Station needed a performance-based check
Halim High-Speed Railway Station is one of the first high-speed rail stations in Indonesia and one of the four Jakarta–Bandung stations whose structures Stadin designed. Key structural facts:
- A 3-storey building with a 226.8 m long railway on the third floor (platform level).
- Structural system: special reinforced concrete moment-resisting frame, with a three-dimensional steel box roof structure.
- High-speed train loads included a standard load (a 64 kN/m distributed load plus four 200 kN axle loads) and a special load (four 250 kN axle loads).
Because trains run on top of the building, the Jakarta Building Expert Team (TABG) regarded Halim Station not only as a building but also as bridge infrastructure. It therefore asked for an advanced performance-based analysis to obtain more accurate and reliable results.
Tip: If your building has an unusual function, such as carrying train loads or heavy machinery, or serving as an emergency facility, ask at the design stage whether the review panel is likely to request a performance check. Planning the extra analysis early keeps it from delaying the permit schedule.
When should owners consider PBD?
Performance-based design does not replace design to SNI. It is worth considering when:
- the building combines functions, such as a building that also acts as a bridge;
- the building is essential, such as a hospital, station or government building;
- an existing building must be evaluated before strengthening or a change of use;
- the review panel or permitting authority asks for it.
Every analysis still needs a model and calculations by a competent engineer. The results depend on accurate data, from member sizes to the reinforcement actually installed.
Conclusion
Force-based design ensures that a building is strong and stiff enough; performance-based design shows how it behaves and how much damage to expect in a strong earthquake. At Halim Station, PBD was used to re-check a design originally prepared to SNI 1726:2012. The next part of this series explains how pushover analysis works. If you need a design or a seismic performance check, our team can help through our structural design and calculation service.
This article provides general information. Every project still needs to be analysed and calculated by a competent structural or geotechnical engineer, in line with the applicable SNI codes and regulations.
Sources
- Annin Hudaya, Sobah Nurul Sodik, James Theofilbert Sabas: Case Study of Performance Based Design Check on Halim High Speed Railway Station Project. Seminar & Short Course HAKI 2022, Hotel Borobudur, Jakarta, 23–25 Agustus 2022
- FEMA 440: Improvement of Nonlinear Static Seismic Analysis Procedures (ATC-55, 2005)
- BAB II Tinjauan Pustaka: SNI 1726:2019, MCER dan faktor keutamaan gempa (repositori Universitas Pembangunan Jaya)
- Data proyek: company profile PT. Stadin Strukturindo Konsultan (2026)