Key points
- Pushover analysis pushes a building model step by step beyond its elastic limit up to its maximum strength.
- The steps: gravity loads first, then a push under displacement control, with plastic hinges at the ends of beams and columns.
- The result is a pushover curve, used to find the performance point, evaluate the R factor and see the plastic hinge pattern.
Pushover analysis shows how a building behaves when an earthquake pushes it beyond its elastic limit and up to its maximum strength. The answer is not simply "strong enough" or "not strong enough" but a full picture of the building's behaviour. This article explains how pushover analysis works, using the model of Halim High-Speed Railway Station as an example.
Part 1 of this series covered force-based versus performance-based design.
The basic idea
Think of a tensile test on a reinforcing bar. At first the bar stretches in proportion to the force (the elastic stage). After yielding, it keeps stretching while the force rises only slightly (the inelastic stage), reaches its ultimate strength and finally breaks.
Static pushover analysis applies the same logic to a whole building. The structure is pushed with horizontal forces that increase step by step until it passes its elastic limit, reaches its ultimate strength and eventually collapses in the computer model. Along the way the software records two quantities:
- the base shear, the total horizontal force at the base of the building;
- the roof displacement, how far the top floor moves.
Plotting one against the other gives the pushover curve. Its straight first part is the elastic stage, and its slope reflects the building's stiffness. As members start to yield, the curve flattens. The peak marks the maximum strength, and the falling part shows strength loss on the way to collapse.
The Halim Station pushover model
For Halim Station, the pushover analysis was run in SAP2000 on the concrete structure only. The steel roof was not modelled as members; instead it was applied as forces on the concrete structure at the points where the roof is supported.
Seismic parameters were taken from both SNI 1726:2012 and SNI 1726:2019, so the original design could be compared with the current code. Because the building review panel also regarded the station as bridge infrastructure, a check to SNI 2833:2016, the Indonesian seismic design standard for bridges, was included as well.
Step 1: gravity loads first
A building never meets an earthquake empty. The first step is therefore a nonlinear gravity load case applied in full at once. In the Halim model it combined the dead load with a factor of 1.0 and the live load with a factor of 0.25. The final state of this case is the starting point for the seismic push.
Step 2: pushing under displacement control
The pushover case starts from the end of the gravity case. The push is applied as an acceleration in the direction being studied (X or Y). It runs under displacement control: the software monitors the displacement of one joint at the edge of the top storey and keeps increasing the push until the target displacement is reached.
Displacement control is used because, once the structure yields, a small extra force can cause a large displacement. Monitoring displacement keeps the analysis stable well into the inelastic range.
Step 3: plastic hinges in beams and columns
In a concrete frame, earthquake damage concentrates in specific zones called plastic hinges. In the model, hinges were placed near both ends of every member (at 10% and 90% of its length), with properties taken from ASCE 41-13:
| Member | Hinge type | What it covers |
|---|---|---|
| Beam | M3 | Bending about the strong axis (ASCE 41-13 Table 10-7) |
| Column | P-M2-M3 | Axial force with bending in two directions (ASCE 41-13 Table 10-8) |
Columns get P-M2-M3 hinges because their bending capacity changes with the axial load they carry. Beams only need their main bending action.
Tip: A pushover analysis is only as good as its input. For an existing building, verify the actual member sizes and reinforcement, for example with as-built drawings and site checks, before the model is analysed.
What the pushover curve tells you
The key result of a static pushover analysis is a pushover curve that yields a performance point: an estimate of the building's actual displacement under a given level of ground motion. With this curve the engineer can:
- Determine the building's performance level, such as Immediate Occupancy or Life Safety.
- Evaluate the response modification factor R the structure really has, and compare it with the R used in design.
- Identify the plastic hinge pattern: where damage appears first and whether that pattern is the intended one.
How the performance point is found is the subject of part 3.
Limits of static pushover analysis
Static pushover analysis works well for regular buildings dominated by their first mode, such as the three-storey Halim Station. For tall or irregular buildings, higher modes can matter. In those cases engineers usually turn to modal pushover or nonlinear time history analysis.
Choosing the method, modelling the hinges and reading the results all take experience. Every building needs analysis by a competent engineer.
Conclusion
Pushover analysis pushes a building model step by step to show how the structure yields, where damage forms and how far it is likely to move in an earthquake. For Halim High-Speed Railway Station, the analysis was built in SAP2000 with gravity loads, displacement control and plastic hinges to ASCE 41-13. For the evaluation of existing buildings, our team can help through our structural audit and evaluation service.
This article provides general information. Every project still needs to be analysed and calculated by a competent structural or geotechnical engineer, in line with the applicable SNI codes and regulations.
Sources
- Annin Hudaya, Sobah Nurul Sodik, James Theofilbert Sabas: Case Study of Performance Based Design Check on Halim High Speed Railway Station Project. Seminar & Short Course HAKI 2022, Hotel Borobudur, Jakarta, 23–25 Agustus 2022
- FEMA 440: Improvement of Nonlinear Static Seismic Analysis Procedures (ATC-55, 2005)
- Analisis Kapasitas Jembatan Eksisting Berbasis Peta Gempa 2017 (Ditjen Bina Marga, Kementerian PUPR)
